6 Concepts of Private Express Trust
|
(1) Trust Property
(2) Beneficiaries (3) Trustee (4) Intent (5) Creation (6) Purpose |
What property can be part of the trust corpus?
|
Any presently existing interest in property that is transferable.
NOT:
Future profits Debt Expectancy |
Who can be a B of a private express trust?
|
(1) Any ascertainable person or limited group of people.
(2) Any corporation (3) Modernly any unincorporated association
NOTE:
Unlimited groups or unascertainable beneficiaries may be the B of a charitable trust. |
Will a trust fail if there is no trustee?
|
NO, the court will appoint one
NOTE:
An honorary trust will fail if the trustee refuses to be the trustee |
Present Manifestation of Trust Intent
|
(1) There are no magic words
(2) Precatory words (wish, hope, or desire) alone will not suffice
(3) Precatory words + parol evidence may suffice
|
Private Express Trust: Elements
|
(1) Trust Corpus
(2) Ascertainable Beneficiaries (3) Trustee (ct may appoint) (4) Present Manifestation of Intent (5) Legal Purpose |
Does a trust have to be in writing?
|
ONLY if the trust contains real property.
The SOF does not apply to trust of personal property.
|
When can a trust take effect?
|
(1) At settlor's death
-Via will -Must comply with will formalities -If will formalities are not met, trust fails
(2) During settlor's life
-Either: (i) Transfer or (ii) Declaration, in trust -Declaration: S is also trustee (living trust) -Transfer: delivery of assets to trustee required |
Is there ever an issue of delivery for a Declaration in Trust?
|
NO, delivery is NOT required because Settlor is also Trustee.
|
Issues that arise regarding "Illegal Purpose" for a private express trust?
|
(1) Fixable illegality at creation
-Court will excise illicit condition
(2) Unfixable Illegality at creation
-Invalidate trust at its inception -Settlor remains the owner
(3) Illegality after creation
-Resulting trust -Trustee must return property to S's estate |
4 Concepts of Charitable Trusts
|
(1) Creation
(2) Beneficiaries (3) RAP (4) Cy Pres |
What is a Charitable Trust?
|
Any trusts that confers a SUBSTANTIAL BENEFIT upon society:
REPS
(1) Religion
(2) Education (3) Poor (4) Sick |
Beneficiaries of a Charitable Trust
|
Society
-There may be NO ascertainable -Incidental benefit allowed -Split jdx whether a small group of B allowed |
Does RAP apply to trusts?
|
Charitable: NO
Private: YES
|
What is Cy Pres
|
(1) Court power
(2) Petitioned by Trustee
(3) Used to modify CHARITABLE trust (only)
(4) IF settlor had GENERAL charitable purpose
(5) Try to get "as near as possible" to that purpose
|
Why is it important to classify between general and specific charitable purpose?
|
Cy Pres can ONLY be used to modify a trust that has a GENERAL charitable purpose.
|
Honorary Trust
|
(1) No ascertainable B
(2) No charitable purpose
(3) CT will not appoint a trustee
(4) If named trustee refuses to act as trustee, trust fails
(5) Almost always a RAP issue
|
Totten Trust
|
(1) Bank Account: "M a trustee for J"
(2) No true trustee or beneficiaries
(3) No fiduciary duties
NOTE:
Watch for words that create present manifestation of trust intent, if these are present, this may be a private express trust. |
3 Concerns of Restraints on Alienation
|
(1) Spend Thrift Trust
(2) Support Trust (3) Discretionary Trust |
Alienation: General Rule
|
(1) B can freely sell or transfer any property interest
(2) Creditors can freely attach to any property interest of B
|
Effects on Alienation: Spendthrift Trust
|
(1) Voluntary
-B cannot sell -Court may allow assignment of payments
(2) Creditors
-Creditors cannot attach -Exception: (i) Preferred creditors (gov, necessaries, child/spousal support, tort judgment) (ii) Any creditor to surplus over "station of live"
(3) Settlor as Beneficiary
-NO, Violates PP -Few jdx allow |
Effects on Alienation: Support Trust
|
(1) Voluntary
-B cannot sell EVER
(2) Creditors
-Creditors cannot attach -Exception: (i) Preferred creditors (gov, necessaries, child/spousal support, tort judgment)
(3) Settlor as Beneficiary
-NO, Violates PP -Few jdx allow |
Effects on Alienation: Discretionary Trust
|
(1) Voluntary
-Not really, what can B assign? -However, if trustee has notice of assignment then yes
(2) Creditors
-Not really, what are they attaching to? -However, if the trustee has notice of debt then yes.
(3) Settlor as Beneficiary
-NO, Violates PP -Few jdx allow |
What is the difference between:
(1) Spendthrift Trust
(2) Support Trust (3) Discretionary Trust |
(1) Spendthrift Trust
-The beneficiary cannot transfer his right to future payments of income or principal, and creditors cannot attach to the beneficiary's right to future payments of income or principal.
(2) Support Trust
-Trustee is required to use only so much of the income or principal as is necessary for the beneficiary's health, support, maintenance, or education.
(3) Discretionary Trust
-Trustee is given sole and absolute discretion in determining how much to pay B, if anything, and when to pay B, if ever. |
Resulting Trust
|
-Failed Trust
-Trustee's duties are to return property to the settlor's estate
-Estate will dispose of the property accordingly (i.e., residue or intestate succession)
|
7 Ways a Resulting Trust Arises
|
(1) Express trust naturally ends
(2) Private express trust has no beneficiary
(3) Charitable trust ends due to impossibility of impracticability
(4) Private express trust becomes illegal
(5) Private express trust has excess funds to accomplish its purpose
(6) "Purchase Money Resulting Trust"
-A pays B to transfer to title to C, and A and C are NOT related -Presumption that C is holding title for A -If Related, presumption that it is a gift to C
(7) Semi-Secret Trust
-NOT a secret trust |
Secret
v.
Semi-Secret Trust
|
(1) Secret
-A WILL that makes an outright gift
-BUT, oral promise to hold as trustee for B
-NO beneficiaries are named or Trust Intent
-PAROL Evidence establishes Trust Intent and B
-REMEDY: Constructive trust; disgorge ill-gotten gain (property given to B)
(2) Semi-Secret
-A WILL that makes a gift to a person to hold as trustee (trust intent)
-BUT NO beneficiaries are named
-REMEDY: Resulting trust (property back to S's estate)
|
Constructive Trust
v.
Resulting Trust
|
(1) Constructive Trust
-Trust implied in LAW -Remedy to prevent fraud or UJE -Constructive trustee must transfer property to intended B (determined by the court)
(2) Resulting Trust
-Trust implied in FACT -Remedy to effectuate the intent of the parties -Resulting trustee must transfer property to S's estate |
Constructive Trust
|
-Trust implied in LAW
-Remedy to prevent Fraud or Unjust Enrichment
-Disgorgement of ill-gotten gains
-Constructive trustee must transfer property to intended B
-Intended B are determined by the court
|
4 Ways a Constructive Trust Arises
|
(1) Profits of Trustee's Self Dealing
(2) Fraud in the Inducement (Wills)
(3) Secret Trust
(4) Oral Real Estate Trust
|
3 Concepts of Trustees
|
(1) Trustee Powers
(2) Trustee Duties to B (3) Trustee Duties to 3rd |
Trustee Powers
|
ALL:
(1) Express (enumerated in the trust)
AND
(2) Implied (necessary to carry out trust purpose)
-Sell -Incur Expenses -Lease -Borrow (modernly) |
Trustee Duties to B
"I C DEALS"
|
"I C DEALS"
(1) Invest
(2) Care
(3) Don't Delegate
(4) Earmark (5) Account (6) Loyalty (7) Segregate |
Duty of Loyalty
|
(1) No Self-Dealing
(2) Remedy for Losses:
-Surcharge
(3) Remedy for Gains:
-Constructive Trust |
Duty to Invest
|
Three Alternative Rules
(1) State Approved Investment Lists
-Scrutinize EACH investment -Never new businesses/IPO -Never 2nd deeds of trust in real estate
(2) CL Prudent Person Test
-Scrutinize EACH investment -Never new businesses/IPO
(3) Uniform Prudent Investor Act
-Scrutinize ENTIRE PORTFOLIO as a whole
*Trustee MUST ALWAYS DIVERSIFY
REMEDY:
Surcharge for losses |
Duty to Earmark
|
Trustee must LABEL trust property as trust property
CL REMEDY:
-Surcharge -w/ or w/o casual connection
Modern REMEDY:
-Surcharge -ONLY IF casual connection -e.g., trustee's creditors attached to trust asset bc trustee failed to properly label it as trust property and not his |
Duty to Segregate
|
No Commingling
-Personal and Trust assets -Trust A and Trust B assets
REMEDY
-Surcharge for Loss -Removal as trustee |
Duty Not to Delegate
|
Trustee may bot delegate decision making duties
Exception:
(1) Professional opinion (2) Modernly only- Money Manager Allowed |
Duty to Account
|
Statements of Income and Expenses to B
Remedy:
Action for Accounting |
Duty of Care
|
Must Act as a Reasonably Prudent Person Dealing with Personal Affairs
NOTE:
ALWAYS discuss this duty |
Remedies for Breach of Trustee Duty/Duties
|
(1) Damages (surcharge)
(2) Constructive Trust (3) Equitable Lien (w/ tracing) (4) Ratify (if good for B) (5) Removal of Trustee |
CONTRACT Liability of Trustee to 3rd Parties
|
Trustee enters into K with 3rd party for benefit of trust
CL: -Sued in personal capacity -BUT may seek indemnification -However, sued in representative capacity IF K so stipulates
Modern:
-3rd party's knowledge controls -If 3rd knows that trustee is entering into K in his representative capacity then ONLY trust assets are at stake |
Trustee's
Personal Capacity
v.
Representative Capacity
|
Trustee can be sued EITHER in his:
(1) personal capacity
-personal assets at stake
OR
(2)Representative capacity
-trust assets at stake |
TORT Liability of Trustee to 3rd Parties
|
CL:
-Sued in personal capacity -BUT may seek indemnification if trustee is w/o personal fault (e.g., an agent committed the tort, or strict liability)
Modern:
-Sued in personal capacity ONLY if trustee is w/o personal fault (e.g., an agent committed the tort, or strict liability) |
4 Concepts of Trust Modification and Termination
|
(1) Modification by Settlor
(2) Modification by the court (3) Termination of revocable trust (4) Termination of irrevocable trust |
Modification by Settlor
|
S ONLY has the power to modify a trust if he:
(1) Expressly reserved the power to modify
OR
(2) Has the power to revoke
-power to modify is implied -E.g., revocable trust |
Modification by the Court
|
(1) Cy Pres
-Charitable Trust ONLY -General Charitable Intent ONLY
(2) Deviation Power: Doctrine of Changed Circumstances
-Charitable or Private Trust -Court is ONLY modifying management provisions (e.g., T may invest in stock) -2 Elements: (i) Unforeseen circumstances on S's part (ii) Necessity |
What is the Doctrine of Changed Circumstances?
|
It allows a court to modify the management provisions of a trust to allow a trustee more leniency IF:
(i) Unforeseen circumstances on S's part;
AND
(ii) Necessity
Ex: T must not invest in stock; T created this provision after the stock market crash (unforeseen that market would rebound); trust will not create enough income without investing in stock (necessity).
|
When can S terminate a Revocable Trust?
|
(1) Majority:
-S must expressly reserve the power in the trust instrument
(2) Minority:
-S has the power unless the trust instrument expressly states otherwise |
3 ways an irrevocable trust can be prematurely terminated
|
(1) S and ALL Bs agree
(2) ALL Bs agree and NO material purpose exist
(3) By operation of law
-Statue of uses: trust real property is idle
NOTE:
Guardian Ad Litem must be appointed to to represent B's who are incapable of representing themselves. |
3 Concepts of Uniform Principal and Income Act
|
(1) Income and Expenses allocated to life tenant
(2) Income and Expenses allocated to the remainderman (3) Adjustment power of trustee |
Income and Expenses allocated to Life Tenant
|
INCOME:
(1) Cash Dividends (2) Interest Income (3) Net Business Income
EXPENSES:
(1) Interest on loan indebtedness (2) Taxes (3) Minor repairs (painting)
NOTE:
These are default rules |
Income and Expenses allocated to the Remainderman
|
INCOME:
(1) Stock Dividends (2) Stock Splits (3) Net Proceeds on Sale of Trust Assets
EXPENSES:
(1) Principal of loan indebtedness (2) Major Repairs/Improvements (new wing on building)
NOTE:
These are default rules |
Adjustment Power of Trustee
|
Trustee may allocate INCOME in whatever manner necessary to administer the trust fairly.
|
